It pains me to say it, but you really can’t believe everything you read– even if it is a bestseller. Take a book like A Million Little Pieces, for example. This was a book published as a memoir by a major publishing house, but the book proved to be a partial fabrication in which the author had embellished major events.
This event was a fairly rare occurrence; most books don’t make it print without extensive fact checking, but somehow A Million Little Pieces managed to slip through the cracks. Major books are not what concern me because reputable publishers will not publish fabricated stories as anything but fiction. I am concerned by the recent surge in self publishing.
As writers, the natural instinct is to publish and have your work read, but the publishing process can be very arduous, and it is understandable that some writers get impatient and self publish. These aren’t the books about which I am talking. I am talking about self-published books on success, spirituality, and personal philosophy. These are books that are, normally, so devoid of any factual material that their authors have no choice but to self-publish. The truly disheartening thing about this is that some people see these published works and assume they are credible.
Recently, I had a conversation with my family that brought this to my attention. Over dinner, we were talking about the Mayan civilization, and how there is some debate about what brought the empire down. A close family member interjected that she knew what happened to them because she had just read a book that explained everything. The book, she said confidently, explained that the Mayans had discovered a passage way to the center of the earth, and that is where they now live. So, I asked what evidence grounded this theory. She explained that it had none, but the author of the book claims he channeled it from god. (Keep in mind, the most printed book in the world is The Bible and its authors make a similar claim.)
Now, this is not a stupid woman, mind you. She is a well-educated, savvy business woman, with a great deal of life experience. I had to wonder how a person like this could be so compelled to believe such an outlandish claim. She told me if I was interested in this that there were a lot of great books I might like to read as well. I said sure, and I looked a number of these books up. Most of these books are self-published, and a number of them are bestselling audiobooks on iTunes. These people aren’t writers, but they are marketing geniuses. I asked this family member why she believes any of this stuff, and she replied that she no longer relies on the credibility of scientific fact, that she was searching for spirituality. I was stunned, I didn’t even know how to begin to reply. On one hand, I admired the fact that she was searching for something deeper. On the other hand, my head almost exploded after hearing this claim.
Now here is what really concerns me. Suppose this claim is true– humor me– and this man really did channel this fact about a civilization of magma dwelling people at the center of the Earth. What is to stop other self publishers from claiming a similar ability to channel un-foretold knowledge from god?
Apparently, there is a market for this type of writing, and apparently people accept it as fact.
Could self-publishing become as harmful as television?
Be a picky reader; choose books from reputable publishers, and help support them, so they can afford to continue to publish with a standard.